Teksonik wrote:Well again to me in this case it's not about simplicity or complexity it's about sound. Take your example of Monobass. I use Image-Line's Transistor Bass which was closely modeled after a real TB303. I don't really care if it sounds like a real TB303 but to me it sounds miles better than Monobass and has added features like distortion modeled after a ProCo Rat which is supposed to be a favorite of those who use the hardware 303, Reverb, Delay, Built in Sequencer. So in a way that does lend itself to simplicity since the effects are built into the patch and you can trigger internal patterns from the Piano Roll.
The same goes for all the Orion synths. The way technology has moved over the years the fact that they haven't been updated in quite some time has all but guaranteed their obsolescence. Wasp has been replaced by DUNE, Ultran sounded great in it's day but something like Wusikstation just kills it now and so on. There is nothing wrong with Orion synths they just sound dated compared to the alternatives available today.
I always hated those integrated sequencers on modeled TB synths. Venom VB-303 was supposed to be a faithful recreation of TB-303, but then dev locked midi input from piano roll with a code you had to enter every time a synth loads, which also failed like 75% of the time. Couldn't even raise the concern about that, the KVR mob would call you ungrateful moron right away for "not appreciating the good free synth"
As good as it may sound, I'm not using it simply for that reason. But I digress. Some people appreciate sequencer being there. I find it distracting, and I'd choose not to use a synth if something is distracting me.
See, reading more about IL Transistor Bass, I'm thinking that Monobass actually has an advantage there. Aside from visually being simpler (not too many controls to look at), you can also choose your own effects. Sure, you'll say that you can do that with IL TB, but to me, MB still has simplicity in its favor - and the looks!
I too am not concerned with authenticity, as long as I can make some decent acid likes on a synth. Most of the time when I want it to remotely resemble 303 with that squelchy sound, I actually use TBstrip synth. I'm sure that many synth sound better than that, so you'd probably call it "dated" as well.
And what the heck does it even mean to be "dated" anyway? TB-303 is
35 years old, yet people still trying to recreate it to this day. Sounding old or retro? Can't really see anything wrong with that, if you're into it. Obsolete? Developers discover new and efficient techniques to program synths, but whether or not that new sounds better is a matter of opinion.
I have DUNE2 that I barely include into my projects. For sure I wouldn't use it for a simple TB line no matter how not-dated (modern?) it sounds. It's a distraction for me when you have a behemoth with a gazillion controls in front of you and you just want to do simple things. I'm in no way near the proficiency with it required to make my own patches, so I flip through patches and if I find something interesting, I'll invest time to edit it to my needs. But do I have to use it because it's not "dated"? If I have to do the simple acid line, honestly, I'd rather use Monobass than Dune.
Here's the bottom line. We live in times where we have options. You can use something or you don't have to. But sometimes you just get used to something that no alternative is good enough. I personally don't know about anything as functional as DrumRack. I love how Monobass, Screamer and Wasp sound and operate. I think Plucked Strings is interesting. I like Sampler's controls coupled with its slicing abilities and auto-slicing of REX files (don't know if other samplers have the same or not). So, if I ever move from Orion, I think I'd really miss those... as dated as they might be. I think I could live without Ultran and Wavefusion as I've used them the least of all those, and there are always samples for drum synths. But that's me. You have other things you value more. And we can debate on this to no end, and we'd probably disagree on many stuff. In the end, like I already said, to each their own.